B. Volatile Organic Compound Exposure
(Tap Water)
In the past, the Tarawa Terrace,
Hadnot Point, and Holcomb Boulevard water
distribution
systems on base were contaminated with
volatile organic compounds (VOCs) )(see
table 2). The sources of contamination
were leaks from off-base and on-base
underground tanks, some of which were
installed in the 1940s. VOCs make up
a group of chemicals having similar physical
properties. VOCs readily evaporate or
volatilize into gases when exposed to
air. Chemicals in this group include
trichloroethylene (TCE), dichloroethylene
(DCE), tetrachloroethylene (PCE), ethylene
chloride, and vinyl chloride and in general
my us used as dry-cleaning solutions,
additives in fuels, or as solvents to
dissolve grease or other compounds.
Tarawa Terrace Water Distribution System
Tap
water sampling in the Tarawa Terrace
water system in May 1982 detected PCE
at 80ppb, a level that remained consistent
during the July sampling. 1,2 DCE was
detected at 12ppb,. Trace amounts of
TCE were detected, but because of the
laboratory instrument detection limit
of 10ppb: TCE was estimated to be 8ppb.
At the time of the 1982 sampling, no
source for the contamination at either
Hadnot Point or Tarawa Terrace system
had been identified (31). Furthermore,
there were no drinking water standards
for these chemicals in 1982:TCE, PCE,
and 1,2 DCE levels in drinking water
were not regulated until the Safe Drinking
Water Act was amended in 1991 (32). Sampling
in February 1985 detected PCE at 215
ppb. Table 2 shows the maximum detected
concentrations of VOCs at the tap and
the current drinking water standard,
referred to as the Maximum Contaminant
Level (MCL) allowable.
Subsequently, it was determined that
contamination at the Tarawa Terrace distribution
system was caused by an off-base dry-cleaning
operation (ABC Cleaners) whose septic
system released the cleaning fluid PCE
into the ground (33). The septic system
was installed in 1954 and used until
1985. In 1985, a well supplying the Tarawa
Terrace system was drilled approximately
900 feet from the dry-cleaners. Because
the well was so close to the septic field,
the well was probably contaminated soon
after it was built. That well could have
contaminated the water distribution system
with PCE for as long as 30 years. Over
time, contaminants migrated into a second
well, located approximately 1800 feet
south of the septic system, but the PCE
contamination was detected before this
well was put into use. In 1985, both
of these contaminated were shut down
(31). Unable to meet the increasing water
demand without those wells, the Tarawa
Terrace distribution system was closed
(28). This public health assessment evaluates
exposures that occurred during the time
for which sampling data are available.
However, the ATSDR study of birth outcomes
reviewed available birth records over
the longer estimated duration (1958-1985).
Hadnot Point Water Distribution System
At Hadnot Point, tap water samples contained
TCE at 1400ppb and 1,2 Dichloroethylene
(DCE) at 407ppb in May 1982, levels dropped
to 20ppb TCE and 1,2 DCE was not detected
(see table 2) (27). The drop in these
levels can be explained by the use of
different supply wells (a few containing
contamination and others not) on different
days. In the Hadnot Point system, any
given well would have been in use about
two-thirds of the time because water
demand did not require using all wells
at the same time (28). There were 39
operational wells in the system, but
only 20 of those wells were used at any
one time. The wells pump water to the
distribution system where the water is
blended and treated. This process means
that although the contamination is them
spread from the one well to the entire
distribution system, it is also diluted
by being combined with water from uncontaminated
wells. Chlorine, fluoride, and softeners
are added to the water before it is pumped
to water towers before distribution.
(28). The possible sources of contamination
at the Hadnot Point distribution system
are leaking underground storage tanks
containing TCE and fuels, spills during
vehicle maintenance operations, and disposal
of drums at Sites 6, 9, and 82 and associated
storage lots in OU 2 (29,79)
In July 1984, as part of the Navy Assessment
and Control of Installation Pollutants
(NACIP) Program, MCB Camp Lejeune conducted
water quality sampling in wells on base.
They found that eight of the 39 wells
in use at Hadnot Point and one of the
seven wells in use at Tarawa Terrace
were contaminated with VOCs. All nine
wells were abandoned and have not been
used in the drinking water system since
1985 (28).
Holcomb Boulevard Water Distribution
System
On January 27, 1985 a generator
fuel line at the Holcomb Boulevard water
distribution
plant burst, leaking fuel into the system.
This situation was identified after the
base received complaints of a gasoline
smell in on-base residential tap water
(31). MCB performed sampling of the system
and found that gasoline had entered the
Holcomb Boulevard distribution system.
The system was immediately shut down
and flushed out. Emergency back-up water
was them pumped from the Hadnot Point
system, whose VIC contamination was not
yet identified, into the Holcomb Boulevard
distribution lines. Tap water samples
taken from Berkeley Manor Elementary
School in the Holcomb Boulevard system
on January 31, 1985, contained TCE at
1148ppb and DCE at 407 ppb (Table 2).
Contaminants measured at several points
in the Holcomb Boulevard system were
consistent with samples taken from the
Hadnot Point Water treatment plant on
the same date. Therefore, the source
of TCE and DCE in the Holcomb Boulevard
system originated from the contaminated
emergency water supplied by the Hadnot
Point system. People were switched back
to the clean Holcomb Boulevard system
12 days later.
|